Skip to main content

AG Barr issues Matter of Negusie, ruling there is no duress exception to "persecutor bar" for asylum and withholding of removal

  1. Date Announced

    Nov. 5, 2020

    ​In ​​Matter of Negusie, AG Barr rules that the "persecutor bar" to asylum and withholding of removal does not contain a duress exception, vacating the BIA decision that allowed for a limited exemption.

    Barr also rules that, if the persecutor bar is an issue, DHS does not have the burden of showing it applies. Rather, the burden is on the applicant to show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that it does not.

    [ID #43]

    View Policy Document
  2. Effective Date of Change

    Nov. 5, 2020
Status: Final/Actual
Type of Action: Adjudication
Subject Matter: Asylum, Withholding and CAT
Agencies Affected: AG EOIR ICE USCIS

Prior Policies

  • In 2009, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the BIA’s decision in Negusie's initial appeal based upon a legal error. The Supreme Court stopped short of holding that there is a duress exception to the persecutor bar and sent the case back to the BIA to answer that question unencumbered by the Board’s previous legal error.

    Negusie v. Holder Supreme Court Opinion
  • In 2016, DHS and DOJ issued an NPRM to explore a limited exception for actions taken by the applicant under duress and clarify the required levels of the applicant's knowledge of the persecution, but the rule was never issued because DHS and DOJ could not reach an agreement.

    Exception to the Persecution Bar for Asylum
  • In 2018, the BIA held that a limited duress exception does exist to the persecutor bar, articulating standards for how an applicant for asylum or withholding of removal could claim duress or coercion to overcome automatic ineligibility based upon "persecution of others." To qualify for the duress exception, applicants must demonstrate that they acted under an imminent threat of death, that they had no reasonable opportunity to escape, and that they knew that the harm they inflicted was not greater than the threatened harm to self or others.

    Matter of Negusie

We require registration to leave feedback. You may either:

  • Sign in with your current user name and password.

  • Register if you don't have a user name and password.