Skip to main content

2.0

USCIS proposes rule removing deference to prior determinations of eligibility on nonimmigrant petition extension requests

  1. Original Date Announced

    October 14, 2026

    USCIS issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) that would remove 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), which generally provides that USCIS gives deference to a prior approval involving the same parties and facts when adjudicating a request to extend a petition through Form I-129, Petition for a Nonimmigrant Worker. DHS argues that deference in practice shifts the burden of proof from the petitioner to the officer. DHS says that the change would better align DHS regulations with the statute, which places the burden of proving eligibility for all immigration benefits on the applicant.

    Comments are due by November 13, 2026.

    Trump 2.0 [ID #2466]

    2026.10.14 USCIS NPRM - Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility

Current Status

None

Original Trump Policy Status

Status: Proposed
Trump Administration Action: Rule
Agencies Affected: USCIS

Commentary

  • 2026.10.24 Forbes - DHS Wrongly Claims An Immigration Policy Did Not Increase H-1B Denials

    According to a Forbes analysis, ending deference to USCIS' prior fact determinations increases H-1B petition denials. USCIS similarly ended deference at the start of FY2018 in a memo, and the change hit continuing employment petitions for existing H-1B employees especially hard, contrary to DHS claims in footnote 13 of the NPRM that ending deference did not increase H-1B denials during Trump's first administration -- USCIS data shows the H-1B denial rate for continuing employment rose 140% after it ended deference. Labor economist Mark Regets says DHS "does not show its work" or explain why its numbers differ so sharply from its own public H-1B data. Immigration attorneys also caution that the proposed rule will harm employers and visa holders.

    Go to article

To provide information, corrections, or feedback, please email IPTP.feedback@gmail.com